Reviews

"Hooked from page one. The mystery, the romance, the psychological tension everything hits. Margot and John’s story feels raw and real, and the question “Is he dangerous or just broken?” kept me turning pages late into the night. A gripping read with heart and suspense."

- Saphira Adams

"The Killer in the Mirror, and what immediately stood out to me was how confidently the author blends mystery, identity, and emotional tension into one tight narrative. The way Margot and 'John Smith', two broken teens circling trust, danger, and unanswered questions, shows a level of character insight that really sets the author's work apart from typical YA crime fiction.

Sharp pacing, memorable scenes, and dialogue that actually sticks. It’s the kind of writing that makes readers feel like they’re watching everything unfold in real time."

- Samuel Nelson

"Super captivating story! It is told in the second person point of view, which can be exhausting for some people, but if you can get past that, you’re in for a ride! Wolf does a great job weaving in suspense, mystery, fear, and anticipation into his storytelling and it makes this book hard to put down!"

- Haime

"Wolf navigates teenagers, high school, and memory loss with the skill of a true professional. As he incorporates his signature crescendos, gapping bombshells, and twisted mystery, The Killer in the Mirror transports us to the foggy mind of a young man with an obvious past. Deftly showing off his ability to create suspense within the mind, John’s memories begin to take shape as Wolf unravels this from dueling points of view.

Using duet narration, The Killer in the Mirror weaves Margot and John into an unlikely friendship as two teens navigate the uncertainty surrounding them. Trauma, history, and secrets combine in a courtroom standoff for the ages."

- Jill Rey

"This was an awesome book. The story line was very gripping. I usually have to skip to the end to see how it turns out for the sake of my anxiety but this story flowed so well I didn’t need to. The narrators are great! I liked how the MMC talked in second person. It really reality type of feel for how someone could go through life with amnesia. He’s living it, but it’s like he’s watching himself live it.

I thought it was nerve wrecking and also clever how the author incorporated the prosecutor who is running for office and portrayed them in a realistic light. A lot of times, they don’t care about the truth, they just need a win."

- Tazja Lewis

"A chilling, emotionally charged YA thriller that lingers long after the final page. The Killer in the Mirror hooked me not with shock, but with unease. This is a story that understands how frightening uncertainty can be, especially when it’s wrapped in attraction, empathy, and doubt.

Margot’s connection to John is compelling because it’s never comfortable. You’re constantly questioning what’s real, what’s remembered, and what might be dangerously misunderstood. John isn’t written as a simple villain or victim; he exists in a tense gray space shaped by memory loss, guilt, and fear. That ambiguity keeps the suspense sharp and personal.

What stood out most was how identity is treated as fragile rather than fixed. The story asks difficult questions: Can you care about someone without knowing who they truly are? How much risk is too much when emotions are involved? The romance doesn’t feel safe—and that’s exactly what makes it powerful.

This is the kind of YA thriller that thrives on mood, moral tension, and psychological depth rather than nonstop twists. If you enjoy stories where trust, fear, and affection collide in unsettling ways, this one is well worth your time."

- Walter McGee

"The Killer in the Mirror is a gripping YA mystery that goes deeper than I expected. The story pulls you in with its intriguing premise and keeps you hooked as layers of memory, trauma, and identity are slowly uncovered. Margot is sharp, guarded, and relatable, and her connection with “John Smith” feels genuine and emotionally charged. The tension builds steadily as his past resurfaces, raising unsettling questions about who he really is and whether someone can escape what they’ve done. Dark, emotional, and thought-provoking, this book blends mystery and romance in a way that feels real and haunting. Definitely worth the read.

- Kate Tilly

"I ordered this book as a birthday gift for my 14 yr. old granddaughter. I thought the cover and the title were intriguing for any age group. Since my granddaughter's birthday hadn't come yet, I decided to read it first! I wasn't disappointed.

Mr. Wolf gave an excellent description of how amnesia can affect a person, especially an adolescent. The book contained several different plots within a murder conviction plot, involving a teen who had no memory of the charge. The book showed how friends can come together to support a friend with no identity. It taught the benefits of being non-judgmental at an age where the opposite is often true.

The book was a quick read, because of the content and the smoothness of the story. I think young people would want to read the story from beginning to end. I know I enjoyed it, and I can't wait to hear what my granddaughter has to say."

- Matt Vogels